Indigenous Australians

In earlier decades, TLM-P was a young man determined to make good in the colony. His focus was on owning a successful rural property and, like other colonists, he did not comprehend the rights of Indigenous owners. As outlined earlier Gaining Colonial Experience, while at Hawkwood station he had no compunction about taking part in a murderous reprisal after the Hornet Bank massacre. Yet the story of colonial conquest is nuanced. When first acquiring Hawkwood, he had ridden long distances with a young Indigenous boy ('Johnny') when he was scouting the land. TLM-P admired bushcraft and physical toughness in men and perhaps largely because of those qualities, commented that, in his experience, Aboriginal Australians with exposure to white culture made good companions.¹⁾ That qualification indicates the huge gap between the two cultures, including language, and that the expectation was that the conquered had to do virtually all the adjusting to the alien culture.

We have more information than usual about TLM-P's interactions with, and attitude to, Indigenous Australians because his daughter Rosie Praed asked him about his experiences which she then used in her books. He dictated to Nora what he knew (or thought he knew) about the Indigenous Australians he had encountered - and, on one occasion, Nora added her own anecdote. TLM-p's memories are a fascinating mixture of brute power and respect; ignorance and at least an attempt to learn Indigenous customs and language, though it is also clear he mostly communicated in Pidgin and used English names for the Indigenous people he knew. TLM-P gave numerous examples of Pidgin speech, and described Indigenous people (almost all men, there is little reference to the women) as having acute powers of sight and observation, a talent for mimicry, and a deep-seated sense of humour.

The complex and mutually dependent relationship between TLM-P and his Indigenous workers at Bromelton is illustrated in his recollections of one who he called 'Charlie'. 'Charlie' had been a potential outcast as he had transgressed the strict Indigenous marriage laws ('she belonged to a caste into which he could not legally marry … [because her caste was] within the [proscribed] degree of relationship'). By his framing it as a legal issue, TLM-P respected the cultural framework of Indigenous life. In recounting how he persuaded the tribe to accept Charlie's transgression, he mentioned that 'their camp was close to our kitchen' - perhaps because both groups needed access to handy sources of fresh water - indicating how closely the competing groups lived with each other. TLM-P pretended that he had had a supernatural visitation at night to say that Charlie, who was ill at the time, should be forgiven. 'Charlie with a little care & treatment soon got quite well. He was a good boy & I did not wish to lose him naturally, so I told him that he must ²⁾ not go with the blacks again or he would die…. (In the mean time I had persuaded the other blacks to forgive him & let him have Sallie) …. Charlie consequently stayed with TLM-P 'for years', but it would be wrong to assume that he was totally subservient to TLM-P. Charlie reminded TLM-P that 'a black man is not like a white man' in that he had tribal obligations: he had been told that he should 'go corroboree, when like it that blackfellow must go“. Charlie went but fell sick & died. TLM-P later learnt that Charlie had 'cried out very much for you' and tried to send a message to take a dray to collect him and ensure he would not die. 'Poor Charlie - had I got the message I should certainly have gone'. This is not to suggest, however, that TLM-P or any of his compatriots rose above his culture's assumption of the superiority of British people, nor of the immense power he could wield with relative impunity. In another incident, TLM-P described frightening Charlie at a time when his horses had all been worked so hard that they were not fit to ride. The exception was TLM-P's favourite horse who Charlie rode when TLM-P was absent so that that horse too was 'regularly broken down'. From Charlie's point of view he is likely he was given a task that could only be completed at the cost to the horse; TLM-P's view was anger that his remaining good horse was not fit to ride. With the help of 'Tinko', a Chinese worker, TLM-P pretended he would kill him - far from a harmless prank given how easily he could do so without legal consequences.³⁾